John Wesley BrooksUse this 35758 home as a measuring stick, not a market verdict. Its size, 2015 build year, Applewood location, and price change give you a checklist for judging any Madison listing. Pair that checklist with September 2026 county data, then confirm the live MLS status before you act.
What does a 35758 home in Madison tell you about the Alabama market?
What this 35758 home says about Madison is mostly about how to compare, not what to pay. This four-bedroom, 3.5-bath home has 3,268 square feet, was built in 2015, sits in the Applewood subdivision, and was listed in September 2026 at $545,000. Those details give you concrete points to measure against similar Madison homes, and the asking price has already moved since then.
Key Takeaways
-
This 35758 home is a 3,268-square-foot, four-bedroom, 3.5-bath home built in 2015 in Madison’s Applewood subdivision, listed at $545,000 in September 2026.
-
A November 2, 2026 search result showed the same 35758 home at roughly $529,900, so any price you see needs a date and a live MLS check.
-
Madison County recorded 627 home sales in September 2026 (down from 711 in September 2025) with 2,814 homes on the market (up from 2,666), so buyers had more choice but fewer closings.
-
Madison County’s September 2026 median sale price was $335,000, while the city of Madison’s separate September 2026 median was $374,000, and those two numbers should never be blended.
-
Headline medians are broad, so the real comparison happens at the subdivision level using size, age, condition, lot, and HOA details.
What This 35758 Home Says About Madison Pricing and Features
It tells you that a 2015-built, 3,000-plus-square-foot home in zip code 35758 was priced in the mid-$500,000s in fall 2026, and that asking prices at that level can still change. It does not tell you what every Madison home costs. One listing is a comparison point, not a market.
What are the property facts worth comparing?
Start with the features you can line up against other listings, according to the Redfin listing record:
-
Size: 3,268 square feet
-
Bedrooms and baths: four bedrooms, 3.5 baths
-
Year built: 2015
-
Subdivision: Applewood
-
September 2026 list price: $545,000
When I sit down with a buyer, these are the first filters I set. Match square footage within a reasonable band, match the construction period, and stay in the same subdivision first. Then widen the search to nearby neighborhoods so you can see whether the price is an outlier or in line.
What does the price change mean?
A drop from $545,000 to about $529,900 means the asking price came down about $15,100 between September and early November 2026. A November 2, 2026 Zillow search result showed the lower figure. Listing prices change, so confirm the home’s status (active, pending, or sold) and the current price in the MLS before you build an offer around either number.
At the lower price, my own arithmetic works out to roughly $162 per square foot. That is a useful screening number, but it is not a verdict. Updates, lot, floor plan, and condition can make two homes with the same price per square foot very different purchases. If you want a read on how this home stacks up, a local comparison from me will tell you more than any single ratio.
Why does the subdivision matter more than the city median?
Because a citywide median blends very different homes. The sources I have verify that this home is in Applewood, but they do not establish Applewood-specific sales statistics. That gap is exactly why neighborhood-level knowledge matters. Floor plans, lot sizes, HOA obligations, updates, commute routes, and nearby development all shape what a fair price looks like on a particular street.
If you are weighing other Madison communities, I have broken down several of them, including Homestead homes in Madison 35758 and Natures Trail homes in 35756. Reading a few of them side by side shows how much a single “Madison” price can hide.
How Do Madison County and Madison City Numbers Compare?
They measure different things, so keep them separate. The Huntsville Area Association of REALTORS® reports county-level data, and a ValleyMLS-based report covers the city of Madison on its own. Mixing the two produces a number that describes neither.
What did Madison County look like in September 2026?
Here is the Huntsville Area Association of REALTORS® September 2026 report for Madison County. These are September figures, the most recent report available, not a real-time November snapshot:
| Madison County measure | September 2025 | September 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Home sales | 711 | 627 |
| Median sale price | $345,000 | $335,000 |
| Homes on the market | 2,666 | 2,814 |
The pattern is more choice and fewer closed sales than a year earlier. The association’s report also points to expanded Madison County inventory through September 2026 alongside lower sales volume. For you as a buyer, that means more homes to look at, but it does not mean every good home sits around. Suitable listings still deserve a prompt response, and the difficult part is knowing which ones are suitable.
What about the city of Madison itself?
A separate September 2026 ValleyMLS-based report covering the city of Madison, published by Hville Blast, showed a $374,000 median home price, 205 new listings, 151 homes sold, and 145 average days on market. That median is higher than the county figure because it covers a different geography and market series.
Use the city numbers to understand Madison as a whole, and use the county numbers to understand the wider market around it. Neither one tells you what a home in a specific subdivision should sell for. For the bigger picture, my 2026 Madison County market breakdown covers sales, inventory, and new construction in more depth.
How Do You Build a Quick, Prepared Search for a Home Like This?
You decide your comparison criteria before you tour anything, then compare active listings against recent closed sales. That order keeps you from falling for one house and anchoring to its asking price. This is the process I walk my buyers through.
What steps should you take first?
-
Set your filters. Pick a square-footage band, bedroom and bath count, construction years, and a price range. For a home like 208 Duchess Drive, that might mean roughly 3,000 to 3,500 square feet, four bedrooms, and a build date within a few years of 2015.
-
Pull active and closed comparables. Active listings show what sellers want. Recent closed sales show what buyers actually paid. You need both.
-
Check status and price history. A price reduction, like the one on this home, is a data point. It does not automatically mean a bargain or a problem.
-
Compare condition and updates. Two homes of the same age can be priced identically and feel nothing alike if one has been updated and the other has not.
-
Be ready to move. Have your financing conversation done and your priorities ranked, so a suitable listing does not sit while you sort out basics.
If you want to see how a home with more features at a similar price compares, I wrote about a loaded Darlington home under $535K in Madison 35757. It is a good illustration of what a budget in this range can and cannot buy in a neighboring zip code.
What should you verify about any Madison address?
Madison is a two-county city. According to the City of Madison’s Quick Facts page, it spans Madison and Limestone counties and had an estimated 2024 population of 64,029, up from 56,933 in the 2020 Census. Do not assume every “Madison” address works the same way. Confirm the parcel’s county, tax jurisdiction, and municipal services for the exact property you are considering.
For a 2015-built home, also plan to ask about HOA obligations, the age and condition of major systems, and any updates the owners have made. Your inspection will show you the rest, and I can help you decide what to ask the sellers before you write an offer.
Does more inventory give you more negotiating room?
It can, but it depends on the specific home. County-level inventory was higher in September 2026 than a year earlier, and sales were lower. That is an environment where a buyer can be selective. It does not guarantee a discount on any one house. A home that is priced right, updated, and well located can still draw attention, so your leverage comes from preparation and from knowing what comparable homes actually closed for.
What this 35758 home says about Madison, in the end, is that the numbers on a listing only mean something next to the right comparables.
FAQ
What features should I compare when evaluating a larger home in Madison, Alabama?
Compare square footage, bedroom and bath count, year built, subdivision, lot, condition, updates, and HOA obligations. For 208 Duchess Drive, that means 3,268 square feet, four bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and a 2015 build in Applewood. Then check the property’s status and price history so you are comparing real, current numbers.
Is $529,900 for a 35758 home in Applewood competitive with similar Madison homes?
Whether it is competitive depends on how it compares with similar homes in size, age, condition, and subdivision. A November 2, 2026 search result showed roughly $529,900 for this 35758 home, down from the $545,000 September 2026 listing price. Confirm the live price in the MLS, then I can run comparables against active and recently closed homes so you see where it actually sits.
How long were homes taking to sell in Madison in September 2026?
A September 2026 ValleyMLS-based report for the city of Madison showed 145 average days on market, along with 205 new listings and 151 homes sold. That is a city-level figure from one month. Days on market varies by price range and condition, so I would not apply it to a single subdivision without current MLS data.
How much house can I get in Madison compared with Huntsville?
It depends on the price range and the specific neighborhoods you compare. The September 2026 city of Madison median was $374,000, while the Madison County median was $335,000, and those cover different geographies. The most useful comparison is size, age, and features at your target price in each area, which I can pull together for you.
What should I check before making an offer on a 2015-built home?
Check the property’s status and price history, HOA obligations, the condition of major systems, and any updates the owners have made. Confirm the parcel’s county and tax jurisdiction too, since Madison spans two counties. Your inspection will give you the physical picture, and I can help you decide what to ask before you write an offer.
Ready to Compare Homes Like This One?
A listing like this one gives you a starting point, but the right decision comes from comparing it against homes that match your size, age, and budget, with current MLS data behind every number. I have spent more than 23 years working Madison and the Tennessee Valley, and I will build that comparison with you so you can move quickly on the right house and skip the wrong ones. Schedule a consultation and we will start with your must-haves and work from there.
About John Wesley Brooks
John Wesley Brooks is a top-producing REALTOR® in Huntsville and the Tennessee Valley with more than 23 years of experience. A third-generation Alabama agent, he helps buyers, sellers, and investors throughout North Alabama. John Wesley Brooks is a licensed Real Estate Agent in Alabama, license number AL-74782.
Capstone Realty · 256.797.2283
Equal Housing Opportunity. John Wesley Brooks is a licensed Real Estate Agent in Alabama, license number AL-74782. Capstone Realty AL license number #153754. Capstone Realty is regulated by the Alabama Real Estate Commission. This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice; confirm your own numbers with your title company, tax advisor, or lender.
The Brooks Family of Realtors has been serving the North Alabama and Tennessee families since 1972.
| Contact 256-797-2283 | [email protected] |
www.johnwesleybrooksrealestate.com
Find me Here: Google Business Profile | Facebook | Instagram | LinkedIn | Twitter | YouTube | Realtor.com | Zillow
